Sunday, April 21, 2013

Bee Kind

Many have debated if Albert Einstein really once said: "if the bee disappeared off the surface of the globe, then man would have only four years of life left. No more bees, no more pollination, no more plants, no more animals, no more man." Regardless of who coined the quote, the plight of our honey bees is clearly in a decline. Mites, colony disease and even cell phones have had the finger of suspicion pointed at them, but a new alarm raise may point the figure at us gardeners.

'The Garden' magazine, published by the Royal Horticultural Society reported; 'that research done by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has identified three neonicotinoids (of which there are seven in the group) - clothianidin, imidacloprid and Dinotefuran as representing an 'unacceptable danger' to bees'. Many of these chemicals have been used widely in agricultural applications, however imidacloprid is found in many garden related chemicals produced by Bayer, while Dinotefuran is used in some of Scotts products.

I've often heard people in the garden center refer to these products containing imidacloprid as 'miracle cures' against a vast array of pest problems. In fact, so good is the product that you virtually don't even need to know what the pest is anymore to be able to kill it. Homeowners freely admit to using the chemicals routinely as a yearly precaution, regardless of whether theirs a pest or not (a practice not recommended until the pest becomes present). Such has become the mindset that even the manufacturers have included fertilizer to further encourage it's sometimes unnecessary routine use.

So what's all the fuss, after all its just a bee, right? Well, bee's are responsible for pollinating about a third of our dietary needs. One estimate puts their worth at around $224 billion for the crops they produce worldwide. If that little yellow and black buzzing machine disappeared the price of food would immediately go up.  Similar to the price of oil, jeopardising food production threatens the domestic security of any country.

Flickr.com - Antie Schulte
One company has even gone as far to develop a vibrating probe, similar to electric toothbrush that comes with a plastic spoon, to help replace the diminishing bee population. 'Vegibee' comes in either battery or in the environmentally friendly, 5 speed rechargeable option for you Prius driving folks out there. It works by placing the vibrating head of your probe against the flowers most sensitive spot, thus making the flower unload its pollen onto a plastic spoon that comes with the kit. Once you have enough of this sweet pollen powder to go around, you can then offer it up to other flowers to score a hit.  It's all very Sex and Drugs, but without the rock and roll.  To think someone actual went to all the trouble to create a honey bee alternative.  Its a shame they couldn't applied the same thought to protect natures original pollinators.  Forgive me, I'm not a capitalist, just a gardener!


So, can we blame these chemicals for Colony collapse? Its not the sole reason for honey bee decline, but the findings from the EFSA study shows enough of a smoking gun to make you thing otherwise. Some garden centers and retail chains in England have already began voluntarily pulling any products containing imidacloprid from it's shelves. Though, the amount removed is nothing more than a drop in the ocean, many feel its a small price to pay. As more publicity arises, many more green industry companies may be forced to reconsider carrying such products in the face of rising concern.

Flickr - jypsygen
If you're like me, your probably holding your head in their hands out of frustration. Yet another chemical is on the verge of being pulled because of its harmful effect on our environment. But, a solution may be at hand. Bayer, the company that brought you imidacloprid also manufactures Aspirin.   Not only will it help you with your pounding headache but studies have shown that giving Aspirin water to your plants boosts their immune systems. One report I read suggests that its like 'giving your plant Echinacea so they don't get a cold', unless of course it's another Echinacea!

So before you reach for that blue bottle of chemical, consider if your plant just needs an Aspirin instead. You'll be replacing one harmful chemical of another lesser one, but at least the flowers can't complain of having a headache when it comes time to fornicating with some help from the bees!

9 comments:

  1. This is all so infuriating! What nature needs is less interference from ignorant control freak humans who want to manipulate their environment regardless of the cost and more understanding of how the whole system works. My garden is 100% organic and I have very few pest problems.

    As for giving my plants an aspirin, considering the largest producer of aspirin is also the same company that produces the insecticides, I'm suspicious of the integrity behind their studies. It all sounds financially motivated to help capitalize on an idiotic public. I'm sure they'll be successful. I know I'm ranting but this hits a hot button with me. Our ignorance has such a cruel edge.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It does feel hopeless at times and your frustration is justified. The aspirin actually comes from salicylic acid that is found in large quantities in willows. The same results can be had by steeping willow stems in water to extract the salicylic acid and spray your plants with that. However, the concentration you get is unknown unless you use aspirin. It's a safer bet than some smelly chemical. Thanks for reading.

      Delete
  2. I think we have to change our mindsets and realise that beneficial insects are being harmed in our quest for the perfect garden. I garden organically and don't really suffer from huge amounts of pests. Those I do have are controlled by hand or, just left to get on with it. I always say, one plant for them and two for me :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would like to think I garden organically but in reality it's me being a mix of cheap and lazy. I can't justify spraying chemicals when they cost anywhere from $30.00 and up. I can buy more plants with that money! Companies that specialize in predicting trends have made strong cases in the fact that many more people are getting educated in how chemicals affect us and predict that the generation X & Y with move further away from the artifical lifestyle. There's still hope. Thanks for writing.

      Delete
  3. I still can't get over the customers who ask garden centers for plants "that won't attract any bugs" --- other than plastic plants, what could possibly fit that description? The news about neonicotinoids is indeed disturbing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your so right, so many customers ask for plants that don't attract bees! The whole purpose of a flower is to attract a pollinator in the first place. I don't think people realize that the bee is somewhat harmless, its the damn wasps that stops you enjoying a beer in the garden.

      Delete
  4. An excellent article of pesticides and bees. It helped me a lot for my next blog which is on ants, bees and other small stuff. Never knew an aspirin could work such magic. Fascinating stuff.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I loved the story of aspirin from the link on the post too. I'll keep a look out for your post, thanks for writing!

      Delete
  5. Great post - I am actually prepping our next lesson for the kids and it is about pollination and bees. I found a lesson involving cheetos to simulate pollen collection - wish me luck! As for chemicals, I am very cautious as I have little kids. I do care about the bees too - without pollination we have no plants and without plants we cannot survive. We need bees!

    ReplyDelete